One stretch of Broward County highway has drawn national attention. A study by the personal injury law firm Elk + Elk and the data agency 1Point21 Interactive, based on 2000–2019 fatal-crash data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), ranked the one-mile segment of I-95 between the I-595 interchange and Marina Mile Boulevard (State Road 84) as the deadliest mile of highway in the United States, with 24 deaths in 23 crashes over those 20 years, as reported by CBS News Miami and Miami New Times. If you were hurt in a crash on I-95 or I-595, our Fort Lauderdale car accident lawyers at the Mike Slocumb Law Firm can review what happened.
The Quick Takeaways
The deadliest-mile ranking is based on federal fatal-crash data. NHTSA collects that data through its Fatality Analysis Reporting System, a nationwide census of fatal traffic crashes, and CBS News Miami reported that its data journalists found the study solid. Keep in mind that the study period ended in 2019, and construction has changed this interchange since then.
If you’re injured in a crash on this stretch, Florida’s comparative fault law can shape your claim. Fault is divided among the people involved, and a person found mostly responsible for their own injuries can be barred from recovering anything. That’s why the evidence gathered in the first hours after a crash matters.
Why Do So Many Serious Crashes Happen Here?
Fatal crashes have clustered around this interchange. The same study found that the 10-mile stretch of I-95 between exits 18 and 27, which includes the deadliest mile, ranked as the third-deadliest 10-mile highway segment in the country, with 146 deaths from 2000 to 2019, according to Miami New Times.

Closely spaced ramps and merging lanes give drivers little time to react, a common setup for serious highway crashes.
In a single mile, drivers face merging traffic from I-595, closely spaced exits, and years of lane shifts from FDOT’s 95 Express Phase 3C project. That project is building direct connectors between the 95 Express lanes and I-595 and modifying the I-95/State Road 84 interchange, with completion currently expected in winter 2027. A local roadway safety advocate quoted by Miami New Times pointed to complicated entrance and exit ramps, poor lighting, and a sharp curve on the ramps near State Road 84 that can catch drivers off guard when they arrive too fast.
What Keeps Causing Crashes on These Ramps?
Merging and weaving. Closely spaced ramps force drivers into last-second lane changes across several lanes, and a vehicle that slows or stops in a merge lane leaves the drivers behind it little time to react. That’s a common setup for a rear-end collision.
Other factors that raise the risk:
- Construction zones: Major work has reshaped this interchange in recent years, and FDOT’s I-595 resurfacing project between I-75 and I-95 is anticipated to run through winter 2029, with phased nighttime lane closures. Construction can narrow shoulders and shift lane lines in ways drivers don’t expect. NHTSA’s 2024 speeding data shows speeding was involved in 34% of fatal crashes in construction and maintenance zones nationwide that year, compared with 28% outside them.
- Commercial trucks: Heavy trucks share the same tight merge space as passenger cars, so a single mistake can involve vehicles of very different sizes.
- Visitors: The safety advocate quoted by Miami New Times said drivers unfamiliar with the area, including visitors in rental cars traveling to and from the Fort Lauderdale airport, add to the risk on these ramps.
- Speed: According to NHTSA, 29% of U.S. traffic deaths in 2024 occurred in speeding-related crashes. On a corridor this compressed, there’s little room to correct a mistake.
What Will the Insurance Adjuster Downplay?
A highway-speed collision doesn’t end when the tow truck leaves. A vehicle totaled on I-95 or I-595 can leave you without a way to get to work or follow-up appointments, and public transit may not cover every trip you need.
Serious highway crashes can cause injuries that need ongoing care, and your doctor is the right person to explain your treatment plan. The losses that typically matter in a claim include:
- Out-of-pocket medical costs, from the emergency room to follow-up care
- Documented lost wages while you’re unable to work
- The cost to repair or replace your vehicle, and to get around while you’re without it
- The pain and disruption the injury causes in your daily life
Vehicle appraisals may not reflect what it actually costs to replace your car. Document everything in your claim, because an adjuster who can’t see a loss won’t pay for it.
What Should You Do Differently After a Highway Crash?
Evidence on I-95 and I-595 can disappear quickly. Skid marks fade, camera footage can be overwritten, and crews clear debris from travel lanes.
- If it’s safe to do so, photograph lane markings, construction signs, and barriers before they’re moved.
- Note the nearest mile marker or exit. It helps pinpoint the crash location in the report.
- Note which law enforcement agency responded, such as the Florida Highway Patrol, and ask for the report number.
- Get medical care promptly. Florida’s no-fault Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage pays part of your medical bills regardless of who caused the crash, but only if you get initial treatment within a short window after the crash. Waiting can cost you those benefits. A medical professional can evaluate any symptoms you have. Notify your own insurer promptly.
- Save contact information for any commercial driver involved. Commercial vehicles may carry separate insurance from the driver’s personal policy.
Keep in mind: Florida’s statute of limitations gives you a limited time to file a negligence lawsuit, and that window was shortened in recent years. Different deadlines and pre-suit notice rules apply to claims against government agencies and to some other cases. Under Florida’s comparative fault rules, your recovery is reduced by your share of the fault, and if you’re found mostly at fault, you may recover nothing. Talk to the Mike Slocumb Law Firm before giving a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer.
Questions We Hear About I-95 and I-595 Crashes
Is fault harder to prove on I-95 or I-595 than on a city street?
Not inherently, but the evidence window can be shorter. The crash report matters less in court than many people think. Under Florida law, the crash report and the statements drivers make to an officer to complete it can’t be used as evidence at trial. Other evidence, such as physical findings at the scene and statements made to other people, may still be admissible. The report’s practical value is in identifying witnesses, documenting the scene, and shaping how insurers assess fault early on. Photos, dashcam video, nearby camera footage, and vehicle data recorders often show what happened better.
Can I recover damages if the crash happened in a construction zone?
Possibly. Florida’s comparative fault rule still applies, weighing each party’s share of responsibility, including how the work zone was set up. If the state or a local government shares the blame, Florida’s sovereign immunity law adds extra steps. You generally must give written notice of your claim to the government agency, and in some cases to the state’s Department of Financial Services, and wait for the claim to be denied before you can sue. The law also limits how much a government entity can pay, and recovering more than that limit usually requires special approval from the Legislature. Florida law may also shield contractors who complied with their FDOT contract documents from liability, with exceptions, so early legal review matters.
Are punitive damages available against a trucking company?
Only as a rare exception. Punitive damages are not part of a typical injury claim. They’re available only where a specific statute expressly authorizes them, and in Florida that authority comes from the punitive damages provisions of the Florida Statutes. Those provisions set a higher standard of proof than an ordinary negligence claim and add separate requirements before a company can be held responsible for an employee’s conduct. A careless driver alone isn’t enough, and most truck crash claims focus on compensating the injured person’s actual losses.
That’s why our truck accident lawyers move quickly to secure driver logs, electronic logging device data, and maintenance records. Those records can show violations of hours-of-service rules or a pattern the carrier ignored.
What if I was a passenger or rideshare occupant?
Passengers usually didn’t control either vehicle, which can simplify the fault question, but every case depends on its facts. If you have your own auto policy, your PIP coverage may apply first. Under Florida law, once an Uber or Lyft driver accepts a ride, the driver or the company must carry much higher liability coverage than when the driver is only logged in and waiting for a request. That difference can matter in a rideshare accident with serious injuries. Florida’s standard negligence filing deadline applies in most rideshare injury cases, but other deadlines can apply depending on who was at fault, so check early.
Let’s Map Out What Happened on Your Stretch of Road
The mile marker, ramp layout, and construction conditions at your exact crash location matter to your claim, and that evidence can disappear on a clock you don’t control. Call the Mike Slocumb Law Firm’s Fort Lauderdale office at (888) 302-3669 for a free case review.
